BOOK DETAILS // WHY ARE YOU SO QUIET? by Jaclyn Desforges, art by Risa Hugo // Expected Publication Date: September 8, 2020 // Hardcover, 32 pages // Annick Press //
AN EBOOK COPY OF THIS BOOK WAS GENEROUSLY PROVIDED BY NETGALLEY IN EXCHANGE FOR AN HONEST REVIEW
OUR CHALLENGE // Read together June 27, 2020 // Book #31 in our 1000 Books Before Kindergarten challenge
Logan and I recently enjoyed an ebook copy of “Why Are You So Quiet?” by Jaclyn Desforges, with art by Risa Hugo. This book is slated for publication by Annick Press in September 2020, so we were fortunate to have early access to the book via NetGalley.
The story of Myra Louise reminded me very much of my own childhood, as I was known as “the quiet one” (and still am to a large degree). Although I was never teased or bullied because of my bookish introversion, I know people were thinking “Does she even know how to talk?” My physical presence was “forgotten” many times because I was too busy observing and listening to the people around me instead of talking and interacting with them. In other words, this is probably one of the most relatable children’s books I’ve ever read.
Myra Louise and I know the pain of having to explain to others why we prefer books to people, and silence to talking. Introverts like us can provide a very simple answer to the annoying question “Why are you so quiet?” It’s nothing earth-shattering, yet the extroverts among us are often confounded by the simple truth: the world is much too loud — and life seems to make more sense when we are listening, not talking. Not to mention how much more we can learn about the world around us when we get quiet for a while.
Overall, Logan and I enjoyed the book, the message, and the beautiful illustrations; however, we couldn’t rate the book higher than 3 stars for at least two reasons. One, we felt the limitations of the ebook format hampered our experience of the book. The artwork is one of the better elements of this title, and it just wasn’t as easy to view and inspect it in ebook format. If we had a physical copy, we are sure we would rate the book one star higher. (Of course, this is no fault of the title itself, it’s just the only option we had at the moment and it does impact our review).
Two, we felt there could have been more time devoted to Myra Louise’s listening machine adventures. The concept of a young child being an inventor is pretty unique and the story just fell a little flat in places. This is not a major complaint, but sometimes children’s books seem a little too short, and I think this one could have been expanded by at least a few pages. Again, a good experience, and we are grateful for the chance to read the book months before publication. We hope to read it someday in print because ebook format wasn’t satisfactory for this title.
It’s a great book for children who might be self-conscious about their quiet personalities, or for children who are trying to understand their more introverted peers. It also serves as a talking point to encourage being comfortable in our own skin — no matter what the world expects of us.
We’ll see you again soon. Happy July!
Forever Between Pages,
Mama & Logan xoxo